CIS contractors: why HMRC is writing to you, and what’s changed

Construction is a big part of the North East economy, so we hear about the Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) every week. Since April 2026, the rules for contractors have become stricter, and HMRC has been writing to contractors to check they're getting it right.

Why has HMRC written to me?

HMRC has been sending letters asking contractors to review how they verify subcontractors and which deduction rates they use. These aren't formal investigations. But they are a warning sign. If HMRC later finds mistakes you could have fixed after the letter, it's likely to treat them less kindly.

If you've had one, don't ignore it. Check your records for the past 12 months and correct anything that's wrong.

Nil returns are compulsory again

If you're registered as a contractor, you must file a CIS return every month, by the 19th, even if you haven't paid any subcontractors. The only exception is if you've told HMRC in advance that you won't be using subcontractors for a while.

Missed returns bring automatic penalties, starting at £100, so a quiet month can still cost you money.

Verify every subcontractor

Before you pay a new subcontractor, verify them with HMRC. That tells you whether to deduct 20%, 30% or nothing. If you deduct the wrong amount, you can be made to pay the difference.

Tougher rules on gross payment status

Gross payment status lets you be paid without deductions, which is a big help with cash flow. Since April 2026, HMRC can remove it straight away where there's a link to fraud, and stop you reapplying for up to five years.

"Knew or should have known"

HMRC can now charge penalties of up to 30% of the tax involved if a contractor knew, or should have known, that a payment was linked to CIS fraud somewhere in their supply chain. "I didn't realise" isn't much of a defence, so sensible checks on new subcontractors matter.

A quick checklist

  • File a return every month, even a nil return

  • Verify each new subcontractor before paying them

  • Keep copies of invoices showing labour and materials separately

  • Check subcontractors' details if something looks odd

  • Fix any errors with an amended return

Work for a council or certain other public bodies is now outside CIS, so no deductions apply to those contracts.

Subcontractor? You may be owed money

If you're a subcontractor, you may have paid too much tax through CIS deductions. Our CIS refund calculator gives you a quick estimate.

How Arvo can help

We're a local accountancy practice in Stanley, County Durham, and we work with contractors and subcontractors across the North East. We can run your monthly CIS returns, check your verification process and deal with HMRC letters for you.

Get in touch to arrange a free, no-obligation chat, or call us on 01207 261100.

Previous
Previous

Taking on your first employee: a payroll checklist for 2026/27

Next
Next

How much does an accountant cost? A plain-English guide for North East businesses